The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings







Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants


New Jersey







Free Updates
A CurtainUp Review
Nikolai and Others

Strip away everything else from a person, and art is what you have left. Some people call this the soul. But I know it as art. Art: our record that we have lived, the breath that gives us life. They can take away our homes and countries, our families, take away our money and beliefs and hopes; Make us compromise and turn us into creatures we do not recognize. Creatures we might even despise. They can do all that – and then what is left of us -- is art. There to remind us that we are human beings.— Except from notes Sergey Sudeikin had made before becoming ill for speech to make at the dinner celebrating his name day. Those notes now read by Nicolai pretty much sum up the play's theme.
Nikolai and the Others
A scene from Nikolai and the Others
Photo: Paul Kolnik
If you asked me to sum up my past week's theater highlights in one quick phrase, it would be "Russia and Russians.

First up on my Russian flavored week was the Encores! revival of On Your Toes (1936). It was a most enjoyable a reminder of how Russian emigres George Balanchine's choreography brought a ground breaking new marriage of jazz and ballet dancing to Broadway musicals.

Next up was the exciting expanded production of Dave Malloy's Natasha, Pierre & the Great Comet of 1812 . This musicalized excerpt of Leo Tolstoy's classic War and Peace was a vivid example of the continued evolution of musical theater's look and sound.

My Russian immersion ended on a more quiet and reflective note with Richard Nelson's Nikolai and Others. As the plot of On Your Toes focused on getting a traditional Russian ballet impresario to put on a young choreographer's jazz ballet "Slaughter on Tenth Avenue" (one of that show's two Balanchine ballets), so Nelson's play brings together a group of Russian emigres for a relaxing weekend of in a Connecticut farmhouse at a time when life in their new homeland is fraught with uncertainties and tensions caused by the Cold War as influenced by Churchill's 1948 Iron Curtain speech. .

Naturally, Balanchine is one of those present. He's now beginning a long collaboration with a composer from the classical music world, Igor Stravinsky. "Orpheus," the ballet they're working on was eventually produced by what was to become Balanchine's long time creative home, the New York City Ballet at City Center. While the play, unlike most of today's economically cast new plays, is weighed down by an overabundance of characters (some of whom are too unfamiliar and underdeveloped and thus confusing for the audience to get a handle on), Balanchine is one of the indispensable "Others" of the title.

The title's specific name goes to the lesser known composer Nikolai Nabokov. As the switchboard character whose role as the go-to-fixer for everyone has stalled his own artistic career, he thus embodies Nelson's theme.

Both Stephen Kunken and Michael Cerveris bring their characters to warm and vital life. Kunken is one of those actors whose name may not ring an instant bell with many theater goer even though he regularly performs admirably on and off Broadway. His latest portrayal is no exception. As Balanchine, Cerveris, one of our best musical theater thespians, proves that he can be superb even if he doesn't sing.

Other standouts among the play's seventeen "Others" are Blair Brown as Vera Stravinsky and her two husbands: John Glover as the current husband and Alvin Epstein as Sergey Sudeikin, the ailing painter and set designer whose name day is to be celebrated during the weekend. Brown's Vera convincingly lets us see her genuine affection for both men. Lauren Culpepper as Anna the young aspiring dancer and niece of the weekend hostess Lucia Davidowa (Haviland Morris) makes the most of an interchange with Balanchine that's Mr. Nelson's amusing bow to the Chekhovian picture of Russians who yearn for a time they can never recapture. his exchange bean amusing

While the Lincoln Center Theater Review as always beautifully and informatively fills audiences in on the play's historic setting and all the characters, Mr. Nelson might have borrowed a leaf from Natasha, Pierre & The Great 1812 Comet. As Dave Malloy fearlessly trimmed Tolstoy's epic, so Nelson might have felt less compelled to use all his research by cutting a few of the people attending his weekend. After all, he hasn't restricted his portrait of a group of people who actually existed to a factual setting but used his imagination to tell their story in an imagined event.

Nelson's device for handling the fact that the entire play is in English by having the characters speak without accents when converse in Russian, and with accents when they speak English is an interesting and effective device. However, like the over-sized cast this is at times more confusing than clarifying.

My complaint about just a few immigrant Russians too many notwithstanding, Nikolai and Others, does subtly build to a fully dimensioned picture of a particular group of people. Like all immigrants they must adjust to a new culture, but as a group of artists find themselves faced with the special dilemma of having to make decisions about not only dealing with a different culture but a suddenly hostile to them political climate.

The weekend spent with their fellow countrymen, feeling free to reminisce about their past and speak only their native tongue is perfectly suited to this playwright's typical slow-building style with its focus on the ordinary details of all human existence. The celebration of Sudeikin's birthday turns into a drama with his illness. The chance to watch Balanchine and Stravinsky work on their "Orpheus ïn its early stages triggers Nikolai's discomfort with his own desire to help his fellow countrymen but also reclaim his own artistic identity. Their need for his continued help and his means for doing so through the powerful "Chip" Bohlen finally takes the casual chatter, dinner preparations, consumption and cleaning up dinner preparations into more dramatic political territory.

The first scene's dinner setup, with the table setting, food serving, consuming and clearing up business, is similar to Nelson's wildly popular Apple family plays at the Public Theater, except that there are a lot more diners here so that not only must dishes and glasses be brought out, passed around and cleared away, but numerous tables and chairs hauled in and out to accommodate them.

Unlike the election day specific Apple Family Plays (That Hopey Changey Think , Sweet and Sad , Sorry ) which had a small cast and a large playing area but a single and very simple set, Nikolai and Others must fit this much larger cast onto the small Mitzi Newhouse stage (a bravo to David Cromer for steering them around fairly effortlessly). What's more, Marsha Ginsberg has designed a set that neatly swivels from the garden party with just a glimpse of the farm house interior, to a barn reminiscent of some of the buildings at the famous Jacob's Pillow Dance Festival for the Orpheus rehearsal, and then to a finely detailed study in the interior of the house.

Impressive as Ms. Ginsberg's skill in creating all these locations is, I couldn't help wondering why Lincoln Center rented its larger theater to the solo play Ann when the Mitzi would have serve it just as well if not better. That would have allowed Nelson's large cast to spread out on the larger stage and the triple scene set could have probably been created as effectively and less expensively.

The production values overall are outstanding. The ballet scenes are buoyed by Rosemary Dunleavy's expert staging and Natalia Alonso and Michael Rosen's exquisite dancing.

Even with the visually exciting dance rehearsal and the emotional fireworks between Nikolai and "Chip" Bohlen this is not for those whose idea of a perfect night at the theater is a fast-paced, action filled play at the most two hours long. But after seeing Balanchine's peppy ballets in On Your Toes, and watching the constantly on the move, flashy Tolstoy inspired musical in its trendy and huge restaurant setting, I found this leisurely visit with Richard Nelson's Russians stimulating and satisfying in its own way.

Nikolai and the Others
By Richard Nelson
Directed by David Cromer
Cast: Betsy Aidem (Lisa Sokoloff), Natalia Alonso (Maria Tallchief), Blair Brown (Vera Stravinsky), Michael Cerveris (George Balanchine), Anthony Cochrane (Aleksi Karpov), Lauren Culpepper (Anna), Alvin Epstein (Sergey Sudeikin), Kathryn Erbe (Natasha Nabokov), John Glover (Igor Stravinsky), Jennifer Grace (Natalia), Katie Kreisler (Evgenia), Stephen Kunken (Nikolai Nabokov), Haviland Morris (Lucia Davidova), Dale Place (Serge Koussevitsky), John Procaccino (Vladimir Sokoloff), Michael Rosen (Nicholas Magallanes), Gareth Saxe (Chip Bohlen) and Alan Schmuckler (Kolya).
Sets by Marsha Ginsberg
Costumes by Jane Greenwood
Lighting by Ken Billington
Sound by Daniel Kluger
Choreography by George Balanchine
Ballet staging by Rosemary Dunleavy
Ballet Master: Jeff Edwards
Run Time: 2 hours and 40 minutes,including one intermission
Lincoln Center Mitzi E. Newhouse Theater150 West 65th Street.
From 4/04/13; opening 5/06/13; closing 6/16/13
Tuesday, Thursday to Friday, 8PM, Wednesday & Saturday, 2PM & 8PM Sunday, 3PM
Tickets $75-$85.
Reviewed by Elyse Sommer on May 17th
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of Nikolai and the Others
  • I disagree with the review of Nikolai and the Others
  • The review made me eager to see Nikolai and the Others
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

Visit Curtainup's Blog Annex
For a feed to reviews and features as they are posted add to your reader
Curtainup at Facebook . . . Curtainup at Twitter
Subscribe to our FREE email updates: E-mail:
put SUBSCRIBE CURTAINUP EMAIL UPDATE in the subject line and your full name and email address in the body of the message. If you can spare a minute, tell us how you came to CurtainUp and from what part of the country.
The New Similes Dictionary

©Copyright 2013, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from