The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings







Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants


New Jersey







Free Updates
A CurtainUp Review
Cat on a Hot Tin Roof

"What do you know about this mendacity thing?. . .I could write a book on it and still not cover the subject anywhere near enough! Think of all the lies I got to put up with!-Pretenses! Ain't that mendacity? Having to pretend stuff you don't think or feel of have any idea of? Having for instance to act like I care for Big Mama!- I haven't been able to stand the sight, sound, or smell of that woman for forty years now. . .Pretend to love that son of a bitch of a Gooper and his wife Mae and those five same screechers out there like parrots in a jungle. . .You and being a success as a planter is all I ever had any real devotion to in my whole life!"— Big Daddy's mendacity rant .

"You were such a wonderful lover. . .Such a wonderful person to go to bed with, and I think mostly because you were really indifferent to it. Isn't that right?" — Maggie
Cat on a Hot Tin Roof
Scarlett Johansson
(Photo credit: Joan Marcus)
One can build up quite a case to support Broadway's evident infatuation with Tennessee Williams Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, his hot and sweaty ode to mendacity in the not-so-old South. One of the most brutal and direct of his plays, it generously provides four attention-getting roles to four ambitious actors ready to turn up the heat on the titular tin roof under the guidance of a talented director.

Four high-profiled revivals have attempted to do this ever since the 1955 play's original and most successful production provoked audiences with its inferences of sexual perversity. None of the revivals, however, lasted more than four months despite some stellar casting coups. The last one in 2008 featured an all-Black cast that was most notable for giving the incomparable James Earl Jones a chance to huff and puff, bellow and to berate those in his presence, as Big Daddy.

In this fifth revival, a good case is made for giving an extended vacation to this fine play unless there is a clear enough urgency and vision behind it. Director Rob Ashford, best known as a director/choreographer (How to Succeed. . .Promises, Promises) appears to be still in the process of envisioning how to gain control of this famously feral Cat. . . the play that Williams saw as revealing "the extremities of human emotions." While that part is in evidence, the actors at the performance I saw gave the appearance of being lost if not egregiously misplaced by Ashford within the extremities of designer Christopher Oram's dreamily impressionistic setting — an immense bed-sitting room showing a section of the wrap-around veranda.

Ashford is certainly fortunate to be working with a more than competent cast that includes Scarlett Johansson as Maggie, Ciarán Hinds as Big Daddy, Benjamin Walker, as Brick, and Debra Monk as Big Mama, each of whom deserve to be seen and heard at their very best. . .notwithstanding the obligatory and overly compensatory display of Walker's admirably toned torso semi-wrapped in a towel.

There is no doubt that Johansson's shapely curves are also going to turn a few heads in her direction as she sashays around in her slip during her lengthy motor-mouthed opening rant. But it would even be hard for Venus de Milo to compete with a virile guy maneuvering a crutch while adjusting his towel around his crotch down stage center. Walker eventually does find his way into the otherwise stultifying Brick's inebriated brain to make him a credible object of Maggie's desire. Deservedly earning praise for his titular performance in the short-lived musical Bloody, Bloody Andrew Jackson> Walker is obliged to add some exhilarating dramatic sparks in a climactic scene he shares with Big Daddy.

The urgency for this production seems to have been to provide a showy vehicle for film star Johansson since she won a Tony for her performance in A View From the Bridge. If Johansson's throaty voice often soundes muffled and hoarse, it could be due to the strain of being heard in the Richard Rodgers Theater, which may simply not be a good venue for intimate theater. Despite the crutch these days of electronic voice control, others in the cast felt the need to shout While initially mired by the obligatory shout-outs and by being up-staged, her performance builds in power stealthily and determinedly like a purposefully sly puss. Johansson is undoubtedly a gifted actor who will undoubtedly adjust to or more likely use to her advantage the obstacles with which she has to contend.

It is also plain that the principal actors can be seen working hard to wrench out the underlying honesty, the savage humor and the genuine compassion of their characters. To this end, they each get their turn hoping we will respond to their various stages of guilt, greed and mortality.

In fact, there are enough exciting displays of guilt, greed and mortality to fuel some of the most exciting scenes in all dramatic literature. The plot, overflowing with talk of sexual perversity and familial rivalry, concerns the attempts of Maggie to get her husband Brick back in the sack, not an easy task since Brick has taken to drinking himself into a stupor since he discovered that Maggie slept with his best friend, whose sexual preference was apparently being put to a test. Disgusted by and with Maggie, Brick is equally unwilling, unlike the rest of the family, to either cow-tow to Big Daddy or connive for control of the family estate.

In general, it is for the supporting casting cast to keep this Cat on its feet. Interestingly Hinds is an Irish-ized Big Daddy who is not only formidable but downright ferocious as the despot of the Delta. His bellowing and bursts of disdain and condescension for everyone except for Brick and Maggie are only a warm up to the physically rough and tumble encounter he has with Brick.

The most emotionally affecting performance in this production is by Debra Monk as Big Mama. Monk, renowned for her stage and TV performances, displays all the essential attributes of the Dixie-bred steel magnolia matriarch, graciously laughing through a barrage of humiliations.

Other impressive performances include the funnily pathetic portrait that defines Emily Bergl's inquisitive Sister Woman, and the nervously distraught performance of Michael Park, as Gooper, her greed-driven husband. But why a dark blue suit on hot summer day? Also, why does director Ashford have Mae and Gooper's four obnoxious no-neck-monsters line up facing the audience to sing "Happy Birthday" to Big Daddy?

It seems odd that Ashford, a noted choreographer, would find that his biggest obstacle is in the blocking, staging and movements of a rather large cast. This is a plantation that is definitely overrun by the patter of too many misplaced feet.

For more about Tennessee Williams and his work, including links to other productions of Cat. . . that Curtainup has reviewed, see our Williams Backgrounder

Cat on a Hot Tin Roof by Tennessee Williams
Cast: Scarlett Johansson (Maggie the Cat ), Benjamin Walker (Brick) ,Ciaran Hinds (Big Daddy Pollitt,), Debra Monk (Big Mama), Emily Bergl (Mae), Michael Park (Gooper), Vin Knight (Reverend Tooker), Brian Reddy (Doctor Baugh).; also Will Cobbs, Tanya Birl, Jordan Dean, Lance Roberts, Cherene Snow. Playing the children -- Laurel Griggs, Victoria Leigh, Charlotte Rose Masi, George Porteous and Noah Unger.
Sceenery: Christopher Oram
Costumes: Julie Weiss\
Neil Austin: Lighting
Adam Cork: Composer and Sound Design
Fight Director; Rick Sordelet Stage Manager: Lisa Dawn Cave
Running Time: 2 hours and 50 minutes, includes 2 intermissions
Richard Rodgers Theatre, Richard Rodgers, 226 W. 46 St.
From 12/18/12; opening 1/17/13.
Reviewed by Elyse Sommer at January press preview
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of  Cat on a Hot Tin Roof
  • I disagree with the review of Cat on a Hot Tin Roof
  • The review made me eager to see Cat on a Hot Tin Roof
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

Visit Curtainup's Blog Annex
For a feed to reviews and features as they are posted add to your reader
Curtainup at Facebook . . . Curtainup at Twitter
Subscribe to our FREE email updates: E-mail:
put SUBSCRIBE CURTAINUP EMAIL UPDATE in the subject line and your full name and email address in the body of the message. If you can spare a minute, tell us how you came to CurtainUp and from what part of the country.
Slings & Arrows  cover of  new Blu-Ray cover
Slings & Arrows- view 1st episode free

Anything Goes Cast Recording Anything Goes Cast Recording
Our review of the show

Book Of Mormon MP4 Book of Mormon -CD
Our review of the show

©Copyright 2013, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from